React Component

One of the most important concepts to learn when developing React apps is effectively splitting a user interface (UI) into components. Components are the building blocks of React applications, and deciding their size and responsibilities is key to creating maintainable and efficient code. In this article, we’ll explore how to balance writing components that are too large and those that are too small.

We'll cover:

Why component size matters.
How to logically split a UI into components.
Best practices for component reuse and responsibility.
The balance between abstraction and complexity.

Why Component Size Matters

When building a React application, a fundamental question developers often face is how to break up this UI into components.

React components can be classified based on size, ranging from very small to very large. Both extremes come with their own set of problems. Let’s examine them.

Large Components: The Problem

Imagine you are tasked with building a card component, such as this one:

const Card = () => (
  <div className="card">
    <h2>Title</h2>
    <p>Description of the card goes here.</p>
    <button>Click Me</button>
  </div>
);

Initially, it might seem convenient to put all the card logic into a single component. However, if this component grows with additional logic or props, it can lead to several issues:

Too many responsibilities: When a component does too many things, it's hard to maintain. Just like functions that handle multiple tasks are difficult to debug and test, a "multi-tasking" component will suffer from similar problems.

Too many props: If a component requires 10-15 props to function, it's a sign the component is handling too much. For example, if the card needs props like title, description, price, rating, and clickHandler, it’s time to consider breaking it up.

  const Card = ({ title, description, price, rating, onClick }) => (
    <div className="card">
      <h2>{title}</h2>
      <p>{description}</p>
      <p>{price}</p>
      <p>{rating}</p>
      <button onClick={onClick}>Click Me</button>
    </div>
  );

Hard to reuse: Large components tend to be tightly coupled to their data and logic, making them difficult to reuse in other parts of the application.

Small Components: The Problem

On the other end of the spectrum, breaking everything down into tiny components can be equally problematic. While it might seem logical to create many small reusable components, doing so can:

Overcomplicate the codebase: A UI built from too many small components becomes difficult to navigate. Developers may spend too much time jumping between files and deciphering abstractions.
Excessive abstraction: Every time you create a new component, you’re introducing an abstraction. Too much abstraction makes understanding the code difficult, as the actual implementation gets hidden behind layers of components.

Here’s an example of going too far with small components:

 const Title = ({ text }) => <h2>{text}</h2>;
 const Description = ({ text }) => <p>{text}</p>;
 const Button = ({ onClick, label }) => <button onClick={onClick}>{label}</button>;

 const Card = ({ title, description, onClick }) => (
   <div className="card">
     <Title text={title} />
     <Description text={description} />
     <Button onClick={onClick} label="Click Me" />
   </div>
 );

While this approach looks neat, splitting a simple card into too many components can make it harder to grasp the bigger picture of how everything fits together.

How to Split a UI into Components

So, if very large and very small components are problematic, what’s the solution?

Striking The Balance!

The goal is to create components that balance size, reusability, complexity, and responsibility. Here’s how:

Logical Separation of Content: Start by thinking about the logical parts of the UI. Each component should represent a clear section or feature of the UI.
- Example: In a card UI, you might have separate components for the header (title), content (description, price), and footer (action buttons).

    const CardHeader = ({ title }) => <h2>{title}</h2>;
    const CardContent = ({ description }) => <p>{description}</p>;
    const CardFooter = ({ onClick }) => <button onClick={onClick}>Click Me</button>;

    const Card = ({ title, description, onClick }) => (
      <div className="card">
        <CardHeader title={title} />
        <CardContent description={description} />
        <CardFooter onClick={onClick} />
      </div>
    );

Reusability: Components should be reusable when appropriate. If a part of your UI can be used in multiple places, extract it into a reusable component.
- Example: A button that can be reused across different cards or forms.

    const Button = ({ onClick, label }) => <button onClick={onClick}>{label}</button>;

Single Responsibility Principle: Each component should do one thing and do it well. A good rule of thumb is that if a component starts to handle multiple concerns (e.g., managing state, rendering UI, handling side effects), it’s time to split it up.
- Example: The CardFooter should only handle rendering the button, while the Card component manages the state.

    jsxCopy codeconst Card = ({ title, description }) => {
      const handleClick = () => {
        console.log("Button clicked");
      };

      return (
        <div className="card">
          <CardHeader title={title} />
          <CardContent description={description} />
          <CardFooter onClick={handleClick} />
        </div>
      );
    };

Your Coding Style: Some developers prefer working with smaller components, while others are more comfortable with larger ones. Over time, you’ll develop your own style of structuring components, but initially, it’s helpful to follow best practices.

Component Abstraction

When creating new components, remember that each one introduces a layer of abstraction. Too much abstraction can make your code harder to maintain. Here's what you should keep in mind:

Avoid premature abstraction: Don’t create new components before you need them. Start with a larger component and split it into smaller components only when necessary.
Meaningful names: Give your components names that reflect their purpose. If a component renders a price, call it PriceComponent. Don't shy away from long component names—they make the code more readable.

Best Practices for Component Size and Reusability

To summarize, here are a few general guidelines for creating components in React:

Component Size Variety: Your application will naturally have components of varying sizes. Some will be large (e.g., a page component), and others will be small (e.g., a button). It’s okay to have a mix.
Reusability vs. Size: Smaller components tend to be more reusable. However, not every component needs to be reusable. Focus on reusability only when necessary.
Logical Separation: Split your UI into components based on logical sections, not just arbitrary chunks of code. Keep responsibilities clear.
Balance Complexity: Don’t overcomplicate your codebase with too many small components or overly large components. Strike a balance.

Conclusion

Building a React application requires a thoughtful approach to component size and responsibilities. By striking the right balance, you can create reusable, maintainable, and efficient code. Keep in mind the best practices outlined above, and over time, your component structure will become second nature.

Now, I look forward to you applying these principles in your next project and watching how it simplifies your development process!

Thinking in React: Balancing Component Size and Reusability

Table of contents